Friday 29 April 2016

Section B exam question

New and digital media offers media institutions different ways of reaching audiences. Consider how and why media institutions are using these techniques. (48 marks)


Recently, new and digital media has brought about a vast amount of changes to the way media institutions reach their audiences. The two case studies that this essay will refer to are the impact of new and digital media to the news industry and the music industry.

It has become clear that the news industry are facing more and more difficulties when it comes to making money. However, new and digital media is making it possible for the news industry to offer their audience a way of reading the news on-line. Last year, within a month print revenues fell 20%, while digital grew by just 11%. This shows that people are more inclined to read their news on-line. In order to continue making money, certain news industries are putting pay walls on their websites. A good example of this is The Times which currently has a pay walls on their website. The Sun also used to have a pay walls until it proved unsuccessful as people did not want to pay to read news on-line.

Many news are now looking to create websites for their newspaper as this is now the best way to reach audiences. In march, the Independent shut down their newspaper in order to concentrate on their website. An article on the guardian stated that the Independent wanted to improve the quality of their website by adding a comment section and allowing the audience to create links to social networking sites. According to the article, the Independent.co.uk website has about 58 million monthly unique users. Other newspaper industries seem to be focusing on their websites such as the Mail On-line and the Guardian. Due to new and digital media, the internet is becoming "an empowering tool" (Al Gore) as the audience are now preferring to receive news through the internet. The new generation are interested in getting instant 24 hour news which newspapers and broadcasting news do not provide. Therefore, "newspapers have to adapt" (Murdoch) by creating on-line websites. 

Media institutions are also trying to reach audiences through social media. People can now receive instant news on social media such as Twitter. Once a topic starts trending, it is available for everyone to see and read all the tweets about the trending topic. Unlike newspapers, social media offers immediacy (Galtung and Rouge) where the audience can watch news live whenever they want. "The most important medium of the 21st century" (Briggs and Burke) has turned society into a global village (Mcluhan) as everyone is now connected through social media. For example, everyone now becomes up-to-date with news events that happen such as the Brussels attacks. Twitter was informing the audience of what was happening as the events unfolded. Media institutions are therefore using social media to reach their audiences more. This is why Facebook brought Instagram for $1 billion. 

Citizen journalism has become increasingly popular over the past few years. The concept of citizen journalism is based upon public citizens playing an active role in the process of collecting, reporting, analysing, and disseminating news and information. An example of citizen journalism is the killing of Michael Brown in 2014. An eye witnesses posted photos of Brown’s lifeless body on the ground, just minutes after he had been shot down by police officer, Darren Wilson. This was then posted on Twitter which brought about much conversation about police brutality. Many cases such as this brought about the hash tag #blacklivesmatter. User generated content is now becoming an important aspect of news as people will view news as more reliable if there is a video provided of what happened. Media institutions are seeing the "technological blossoming" (Castells) of citizen journalism and are taking advantage of the change that new and digital media has brought about. News broadcasters such as Sky News and BBC News are now accepting user generated content sent to them by the audience. 

Periscope is another aspect of citizen journalism. Periscope is Twitter's new live-streaming video app where you are able to watch and broadcast live video from all across the globe whether it is a protest or someone walking to work. Periscope has been called irrelevant because people spend ours watching what other people are doing around the world which is "dumbing us down" (Keen). However, there are other media institutions that are creating social networking sites that involve user generated content.

New and digital media has also effected the music industry as people are more inclined to download music or listen to music on streaming services rather than buying CD's. Now, new and digital media has changed the way institutions distribute music. Spotify offers a vast library of music that is available at any time. Music videos are available anytime on YouTube and can be downloaded and played on mobile devices. Digital radio can be listened to on computers and mobile devices. Music is available as electronic data files. Bloggers can set up their own versions of the music press offering reviews and commentary. Streaming services such as Spotify offer industries different ways to reach audiences.

A Marxist perspective would argue that the so-called "information revolution" has done little to benefit audiences or to subvert the established power structures in society. Far from being a “great leveller” (Krotoski, 2012) as many have claimed, it has merely helped to reinforce the status quo by promoting dominant ideologies. The most popular news website in the UK by a considerable margin is the ‘Mail Online’, which receives more than 8 million hits every month and is continuing to expand rapidly – with forecasts that it will make £100 million or more in digital revenues in the next three years. Similar to its tabloid print edition, the website takes a Conservative, right-wing perspective on key issues around gender, sexuality and race and audiences appear to passively accept what the Marxist theorist, Gramsci, called a hegemonic view. When one of their chief columnists, Jan Moir, wrote a homophobic article about the death of Stephen Gately in 2009 there were Twitter and Facebook protests but, ultimately, they did not change the editorial direction of the gatekeepers controlling the newspaper.

In a pluralist view, the development of new and digital media means the audience is more powerful especially in terms of consumption and production. Pluralists believe in an active audience who chose what media to consume and they don't have to swallow what the media feeds them. In a sense, they get to conform, accommodate or reject the media that they are shown. New and digital media has given the audience the possibility to do so much hence why it is described as "the most important medium of the twentieth century" (Briggs and Burke). In fact the audience is capable of manipulating the media and producing their opinions on-line. A good example of this is the Arab spring; the democratic uprising that arose independently & spread across the Arab world in 2011. The movement originated in Tunisia in December 2010 and quickly took hold in places such as Egypt and Libiya due to the effective use of social media to organize, communicate, and raise awareness in the face of state attempts at repression and Internet censorship. Facebook and Twitter were tools people in Egypt used to exchange information globally. The Facebook group helped organize over 100,000 people to protest on Egypt's police day, originally the Facebook page aimed for 50,000 people to protest. The protest overall led to political changes in the several countries, a change to a more democratic political regime. Therefore, the audience was able to cause democratization due to the powerful help of social media.

Thursday 21 April 2016

Notes: Issues in journalism: mainstream vs social media

Citizen journalism
  • changed the nature of how we consume & understand news
  • changed the way mainstream media outlets report news

Ethical Considerations
  • Privacy
  • graphical videos
  • dehumanising to victims
  • spreading the terrorists' propaganda

Positives of relying on UGC
  • Acts as a witness to the truth

Negatives of relying on UGC
  • Quality isn't great; identifying the source is difficult& verification is also difficult.

What is the intention on spreading the video?

Mobile phone tech. provides content for news channels

Social media has brought in content & provides the news with a platform to broadcast news.

"False information spreads just like accurate information"- Fainda Vis

People use to sit down at the same time each day to watch the news. (An appointment to view)
Generally news values hasn't changed (e.g immediacy due to verification)

The internet has changed things as you can share any content whether its graphic or not.
Binlardin  used Aljeezera to promote AlKhida.

Digital divide- haves & haves not of the internet

BBC wont show graphic videos in the future (opinion) as they will want to protect their audience and the laws that are set.

Monday 18 April 2016

(64) Publishing platform Medium may be blocked in China, reports say

Link: http://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/apr/15/medium-blocked-china-internet-censorship

china internet blog
 
Summary:
 
A US-based online publishing platform, Medium, has been blocked in China, according to users and tests by Reuters, the latest service to apparently be affected as Beijing exerts greater control over the internet. Medium, which allows users, including companies and media outlets, to post blogs that readers can annotate, has been inaccessible since at least early this week, according to internet users in China and tests by Reuters using tools developed by anti-censorship watchdog GreatFire.org. It was not immediately apparent why Medium was blocked. China has moved to limit access to coverage of the matter and has censored online reports about it. Officials say internet restrictions are needed to ensure security in the face of rising threats, such as terrorism.
 
Key data/statistical information:
 
  • San Francisco-based Medium did not respond to emailed questions outside normal US working hours
  • Also last week, Medium said more than a dozen media outlets would start publishing on its site, an arrangement that would have allowed publications whose websites are blocked in China to reach users in the country
  • The websites of several major media outlets are also blocked, including those of the Economist and Time, which both become inaccessible last week after they ran articles critical of President Xi Jinping
 
What's my view?
 
This shows security issues. Also, from a Marxist view, it shows that the elite people still have control over what the audience is allowed to see. Not every country has reached the same level of freedom to conform to media as western countries have. Major censorship seems to be happening in China.

(63) How newsroom pressure is letting fake stories on to the web

Link: http://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/apr/17/fake-news-stories-clicks-fact-checking

McDonald's
 
Summary:
 
“This guy’s story about trying to buy a McDonald’s milkshake turned into a bit of a mission and the internet can’t get enough of it,” read the headline on Indy100, the Independent’s sister title. The New York Daily News said he’d been “tortured”. Except, as McDonald’s pointed out – and Raby himself later admitted – the story was embellished to entertain his Twitter followers, although he says he based it on real events. Binkowski says that, during her career, she has seen a shift towards less editorial oversight in newsrooms. “Clickbait is king, so newsrooms will uncritically print some of the worst stuff out there, which lends legitimacy to – in a word – bull****. Not all newsrooms are like this, but a lot of them are.” The Guardian has heard numerous accounts from journalists about the pressures in UK newsrooms that lead to dodgy stories being reported uncritically, but none would go on record. “There is definitely a pressure to churn out stories, including dubious ones, in order to get clicks, because they equal money.

Key data/statistical information:

  • Facebook, a source of a lot of traffic from many online titles, has recognised the role it plays in driving the market, and in January 2015 promised to tweak its algorithm to demote fake news articles in users’ feeds.
  • In a February 2015 report for the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia University, Craig Silverman wrote: “Journalists have always sought out emerging (and often unverified) news. They have always followed on the reports of other news organisations. But today the bar for what is worth giving attention seems to be much lower.
  • In September 2015, the Brisbane Times was one of many titles to report the story of Natalie Amyot, a French tourist who had posted a video on YouTube saying she was seeking help to find a man with whom she’d had a one-night stand after discovering that she was pregnant. The same title reported the following day that it had been a set-up.
  • In June 2014, Huffington Post and Mail Online were among those to report that three-year-old Victoria Wilcher, who had suffered facial scarring, had been kicked out of a KFC because she was frightening customers. Later, both the Mail and Huffington Post were among those reporting KFC’s announcement that two investigations had found no evidence to support the claims.

What's my view?

This shows how unreliable the internet is but also the news. We can't believe everything the news says as it can be inaccurate. Verification and fact-checking are regularly falling prey to the pressure to bring in the numbers, and if the only result of being caught out is another chance to bring in the clicks, that looks unlikely to change.

Ignite presentation

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B7bjEwKhOpzeMmR2QXoyY1BKY0U/view?usp=sharing

Monday 11 April 2016

(62) Twitter to live stream NFL's Thursday night football

Link: http://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/apr/05/twitter-stream-nfl-thursday-night-football

Twitter is to live stream NFL’s Thursday night football.
 
Summary:
 
Twitter users will be able to watch live Thursday night American football games after the tech company became the surprise winner in a bidding war that included Amazon and Yahoo. Ten games from the NFL’s regular season will be broadcast on Twitter, as well as in-game highlights and live pre-game interviews on its streaming platform, Periscope. The NFL commissioner, Roger Goodell, added: “Twitter is where live events unfold and is the right partner for the NFL as we take the latest step in serving fans around the world live NFL football. There is a massive amount of NFL-related conversation happening on Twitter during our games and tapping into that audience in addition to our viewers on broadcast and cable, will ensure Thursday night football is seen on an unprecedented number of platforms this season.”

Key data/statistical information:

  • The games will be available to people Twitter counts as users even if they are not registered, meaning a potential audience of 800 million
  • Verizon will also retain the US mobile rights to stream all 16 games following a deal in 2010
  • The move has surprised the tech industry, with Amazon tipped as the more likely buyer given its previous willingness to pay large sums for TV rights, such as the reported £160m it paid to secure the services of former Top Gear presenters Jeremy Clarkson, James May and Richard Hammond
  • Last year, Yahoo paid $20m to show the first NFL game of the season live online
  • US tech site Recode has reported that the new deal is worth under $10m (£7.1m), with Twitter winning despite larger rivals bidding as much as $15m
  • A tweet from Twitter’s investor relations account saying the deal would not affect financial guidance for 2016 provided earlier this year also suggest the deal is far smaller than the combined $450m NBC and CBS paid to each broadcast five games

What's my view?

This is evidence of the changes that are being made because of new and digital media. Twitter has taken advantage of its popularity and will do a live stream of the important football match. This means more and more people will be watching it on-line rather than traditionally watching it on the TV. This shows that this generation prefers to have things on-line as they view the internet as a global village (McLuhan) where they can share their opinions and ideologies on-line for people to see.

(61) Daily Mail goes nuclear over Barack Obama 'peace sign'

Link: http://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/apr/05/daily-mail-barack-obama-peace-sign-president

Barack Obama: two fingers to accuracy from the Daily Mail.
 
Summary:
 
In typically breathless style last week the Daily Mail website drew attention to the leader of the free world leading the free world at a Washington summit on nuclear security. One piece
picked out a special moment caught on camera when Obama, in keeping with his hip image, flashed the peace sign at the camera. As the Mail’s triple decker headline put it: “Peace out, fools! Obama plays the clown by flashing the peace sign for nuclear security summit ‘team photo’... and gets a very unimpressed look from David Cameron and bemused world leaders.” The Independent went for the more restrained: “Obama flashes peace sign during world leaders photoshoot at nuclear security summit.” Except, of course, he didn’t. As helpfully shown in the video embedded below the Mail story, Obama was in fact indicating with his fingers (and saying audibly) that: “We’ve got two more folks we’re waiting on.”

Key data/statistical information:


What's my view?

This shows that we shouldn't always trust what is published in the news. Not only can it be unreliable but it can also be inaccurate.

Monday 4 April 2016

(60) The Times drops online rolling news for four editions a day

Link: http://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/mar/30/times-rolling-editions-website-sunday-times-apps

The Times and Sunday Times have merged their websites and launched new apps.
Summary:
 
The Times and Sunday Times will cease publishing rolling news on their digital platforms and move to set editions across the day as the titles launch new mobile apps and a redesigned website. An edition will be produced each day for all platforms, then updated on digital ones at 9am, midday and 5pm on weekday – and at midday and 6pm on weekends. The titles will still follow big breaking stories at editors’ discretion, they said. Senior editors believe the edition-based publishing model will reflect their readers’ daily routines and allow Times and Sunday Times journalists to produce more considered work than they could on a rolling deadline.

Key data/statistical information:

  • The power of an edition has endured at the Times for more than 230 years
  • The Times and Sunday Times have been expected to revamp their digital offerings for a long time and the prospect of edition-based publishing was raised almost exactly a year ago
  • The Times and Sunday Times have digital subscriptions of 172,000 across seven days, figures released by the company show
  • In 2013, it was reported that they had 150,000 subscribers

What's my view?

The fact that The Times is trying to improve their website and get onto the mobile platform. New and digital media has changed the way the audience like to read their news and one of the key ways people like to read their news is on-line through the usage of their phone.

(59) Using Twitter and Facebook images of tragedies raises ethical dilemmas

Link: http://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/mar/24/twitter-facebook-images-ethical-dilemmas-mobile-social-media

Passengers walk on Metro tracks to be evacuated after an explosion at Maelbeek train station in Brussels.
 
Summary:

If you looked across social media as news of the Brussels attacks unfolded, you would have seen that within minutes of the first reports of explosions at Zaventem airport, people were lashing out. And plenty of the lashing out was at journalists, especially those contacting members of the public to see if images they had posted of the attack were available for re-use. Breaking news situations and social media are an ongoing ethical challenge for journalists. There’s clearly a public interest in reproducing the images, and it seems surely preferable to contact a witness and ask them for permission to use their images with a credit, rather than just ripping them off and using them anyway. The proliferation of cameras in people’s hands, embedded in their phones, connected to the web, has changed reporting of events like Brussels. News organisations no longer have to rely on professional photographers or camera people getting to the scene of a dramatic event several hours after it has happened, and getting some pictures of police tape cordoning off a place where something quite clearly isn’t happening any more. We now get footage of nearly every news event in western Europe or the US from someone near the scene almost instantly. It is a shift that has happened over the past decade.
 
Key data/statistical information:
 
  • One of the most iconic images from London’s 7/7 bombings was of people moving through a tunnel along the tracks, taken by someone who had narrowly avoided the carnage
  • It is instructive to think back to how 9/11 was covered, and how that would be different today
  • Had that attack taken place in 2011, rather than 2001, it is almost certain that some of the 1st images journalists would have had would have been people in the south tower of the World Trade Center, taking photographs of the north tower in flames, and posting it to social media, unaware that United Airlines Flight 175 was at that moment on course to hit the building they were standing in
 
What's my view?
 
This ethical dilemma shows the rise in and new and digital media has its pros and cons. New and digital media has paved the way for citizen journalism which involves user generated content being produced by those who were at the scene of the incident. There seems to now be a debate on whether people need to ask permission when taking the owners user generated content of an event.


Sunday 3 April 2016

MEST3 mock exam - Learner Response

1)  WWW- Some good insight and good use of media terminology

EBI- Lacks explicit focus/ reference to the question, especially in the introduction- please re-do this. Also, more needed on UGC, with specific examples- please add to this.

2) Read through the
mark scheme. Pay particular attention to page 9 that has suggested content for each of the questions in Section A. How many of these potential points did you make? Did you successfully answer the questions?

For Question 1 most of the points were made in my answers. Question 2 and 3 are weaker as I did not make many points and did not answer the question to a great extent.

3) Now look at page 15 of the mark scheme. How many of the broad areas suggested by AQA did you cover in your Section B essay? Did you successfully answer the question?


I was able to cover most points apart from globalisation. I successfully answered the question but I need to make reference to the question more in my essay. Also, the point of agenda setting via production, needed to be expanded into greater detail.

 4) Read the
Examiner's Report in full. For each question, would you classify your response as one of the stronger answers or one of the weaker answers the Chief Examiner discusses? Why? What could you do differently next time? Write a reflection for EACH question in the paper.

Question 1 and question 6 would be classified as somewhat strong answers however question 2 would due to the lack of detail and examples used in my answer.
Question 3 would need some improvements in order to be classed as a strong answer.

5) Choose your weakest question in Section A and re-write an answer in full based on the suggested content from the Examiner's Report. This answer needs to be comprehensive and meet the criteria for Level 4 of the mark scheme. This will be somewhere between 3-6 well-developed paragraphs (depending on the number of marks).

Question 2
In what ways are issues of personal identity presented in the media?
You may refer to other products to support your answer.

Issues of personal identity is presented in the media is several ways. For instance, in the Nexus 5 smartphone advertisement we see identities being shown through the visual image of different cultures, different ways of love, getting married and proposing. Same sex marriage was also presented to show that all identities can be invited to use this phone.

In "What's your identity?" video, the rhetorical questions share the different ways people identify themselves, either through success, mistakes or experience.

Another way issues are presented in the media is through the different films and music that are available for people to see that demonstrate equality. Nowadays, there are gay couples and the sense of gay love in films and music videos. An example of this would be the song Same Love that was sung by Macklemore which presented the issue of same sex marriage and love in the music video and lyrics.

Social media also plays a part in presenting the issues of personal identity. People use social networking sites such as Facebook and Twitter to reveal their personal identity. However than bring out pros and cons. Identity theft is one of the problems with social networking sites. People are stealing each others pictures and claiming to be that person when they speak to others on-line. This means that personal identity may not always be true or what it seems on-line. However, people can social media to their benefit as those who are shy can present their true identity on-line and show others what they like and dislike.